From loyalty programs to live games: how brand loyalty evolved
Punch cards, points, status tiers, badges, and now live games. Here is how brand loyalty evolved, why each stage ran out of road, and what a live game gives a brand that a points balance never could.
7 min read Resonance
Brand loyalty moved from punch cards to points, then to status tiers, then to gamification, and is now moving to live games, because each stage rewarded transactions while people increasingly wanted something to do, someone to do it with, and a reason to come back that was not a discount. This is the short history of that shift, and it is also the story of how Resonance started.
Stage one: the punch card
The oldest loyalty mechanic is a card with boxes. Buy ten coffees, get one free. It is simple, it is honest, and it works better than it should.
Behavioral research later explained why. In a well-known study, Nunes and Drèze (2006) gave car-wash customers one of two cards. One needed eight stamps and started empty. The other needed ten stamps but came with two already stamped. The work left was identical, yet the head-start card was completed far more often, roughly 34% against 19%. This is the endowed progress effect: people who feel they have already started are more likely to finish.
Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng (2006) found a related pattern in a café reward program. Members bought coffee more often the closer they got to the free one. That is the goal-gradient effect. Punch cards worked because they made progress visible and finite.
Their limit was just as clear. A punch card has one goal, one reward and no story. Once the free coffee is claimed, the loop resets to zero, and nothing about the brand has become more interesting.
Stage two: points
Points programs generalised the punch card. Instead of one product and one reward, every purchase earned a currency that could be spent across a catalogue. Airlines, supermarkets and card issuers built huge programs this way.
Points solved scale, not meaning. A points balance is an abstract number tied to spending, and the main question it answers is "how much off do I get?" When every competitor runs the same scheme, points stop being a reason to choose a brand and become a cost of doing business.
Points also reward the transaction, not the relationship. They give a customer nothing to do between purchases.
Stage three: status tiers
Tiers added identity. Airline status, hotel elite levels and beauty programs such as Sephora Beauty Insider gave members a name for where they stood and visible perks that came with it.
Status works because it taps something real: people care about recognition and about not losing what they have built. Loss aversion, described by Kahneman and Tversky, explains why a member will take an extra flight to keep a tier.
But tiers still sit on top of spending. The way up is to buy more. For a brand with a community that talks, creates and shows up, but does not buy every week, tiers measure the wrong thing.
Stage four: gamification
In the 2010s, brands started borrowing from games. Deterding and colleagues (2011) defined gamification as "the use of game design elements in non-game contexts": badges, progress bars, leaderboards, challenges and streaks.
Some of it was excellent. Duolingo streaks gave learners a daily reason to return. Nike Run Club challenges turned solo runs into shared goals. Starbucks Rewards made its stars feel like a small game rather than a ledger.
A lot of it was not. Badges were stuck onto products with nothing behind them. Leaderboards rewarded whoever spent most. And brands ran into a problem psychologists had already described. Self-Determination Theory, from Deci and Ryan, says people are driven by autonomy, competence and relatedness. Pay people for something they already enjoy and the reward can crowd out the enjoyment. That is the overjustification effect, and it is why "points for posting" so often produces spam rather than community. We go deeper on this in our guide to Self-Determination Theory and community engagement.
Most gamification was elements without a game. A badge is a game element. A world worth returning to is a game.
Stage five: brands inside live games
At the same time, games themselves changed. The biggest ones stopped being products you finish and became places you return to, with seasons, limited-time events and a calendar that never ends. The industry calls this LiveOps.
Brands noticed. Concerts and branded islands in Fortnite and Roblox showed that people would happily spend time with a brand inside a game, if the experience was good. Pine and Gilmore anticipated this in The Experience Economy (1998): staged, memorable experiences are a distinct kind of value, beyond goods and services.
The catch was cost. Building a game is slow and expensive, and running one needs a team shipping content every week. A one-off branded experience lasts a few weeks, then the audience has nowhere to go.
Where Resonance came from
Resonance started as a loyalty idea. The idea was to reward the people who show up for a brand, in Discord and elsewhere, for things they already do: real conversation, helping a new member, turning up to a voice event.
But we hit the same wall the industry had hit. A reward balance with nothing to spend it on, and nothing to do between rewards, does not hold attention for long. People wanted a reason to care about the reward, not a bigger number.
So the rewards got somewhere to go. They became ingredients in a kitchen, gear for a journey, Avatars to forge and a roster to take into the Arena. The loyalty layer turned into a live game world, and that world now runs its own calendar of seasons and events.
Today Resonance makes IP playable. That is the next step after live games: a brand brings its world, characters and community, and Resonance turns them into places and heroes inside a live game played in the browser and on Discord, kept alive by its LiveOps engine. Our guide to playable IP explains the idea in full. Players sign in with email and nothing needs installing.
Brands plug into that calendar to run their own events, seasons and collaborations, without building a game or hiring a live-ops team. The pillar guide, what LiveOps means for brands, explains the model in full.
What changed, stage by stage
| Stage | What it rewards | Where it runs out |
|---|---|---|
| Punch card | Repeat purchase | One goal, then reset |
| Points | Spend | Abstract, interchangeable |
| Tiers | Higher spend | Ignores non-buying fans |
| Gamification | Tracked actions | Elements without a game |
| Live games | Play, contribution, community | Costly to build and run alone |
Live games keep what worked earlier, such as visible progress, recognition and streaks, and put it inside a world with things to do, people to do them with, and something new every season.
What this means for a brand today
You do not need to choose between a loyalty program and a game. The useful question is: what do your people do between purchases, and does anything reward it?
- Reward behavior, not just spend. Showing up, helping others and taking part are worth recognizing.
- Give rewards a destination. A reward with a use inside a world people enjoy is worth more than a larger balance.
- Run on a calendar. A single campaign spikes and fades. A season gives people a reason to come back next week.
- Keep it fair. In Resonance, ranked play and PvP cannot be bought. Paid options sell convenience or cosmetics, never rank.
For a concrete example, the Talettra case study shows a six-month live event built this way. If you want to see how the tiers work, start with Resonance for brands.
Common questions
Are loyalty programs still effective?
Many still work for repeat purchase, especially when progress is visible and finite. They are weaker at building a community or giving people a reason to engage between purchases, which is where games do better.
What is the difference between a loyalty program and gamification?
A loyalty program rewards transactions, usually with points or tiers. Gamification adds game elements such as streaks, badges and challenges to reward behavior. A live game goes further, giving those rewards a world to be used in.
Is Resonance a loyalty points program?
No. It began as a loyalty idea, but it is now a live game world that brands run events inside. Rewards are in-game value for play, not a points balance tied to spending, and it is not play-to-earn.
Do brands need to build their own game to do this?
No. Brands compose events from existing modules and launch them to players already in the game. Setup is assisted and usually takes days.
Ready to move past points? See how brands work with Resonance and start free with Tuned In.
- loyalty programs
- gamification
- liveops
- brand engagement
- history
Keep reading
-
Guides6 min read
A Discord leveling bot with a whole game attached
Leveling bots are one of the most common ways to keep a Discord server talking, and most of them run out of steam. Here is why, and what changes when the levels lead somewhere: a live game and a season your whole server plays together.
-
Guides4 min read
Playable IP vs. branded Roblox and Fortnite experiences: what's the difference?
Branded worlds in Roblox and Fortnite proved that people will happily spend time with a brand inside a game. Playable IP takes the same idea somewhere it can last. Here is how the two compare, and when each makes sense.
-
Guides7 min read
What is playable IP? How brands turn their world into a game people play
Most IP is something people watch, hold or buy. Playable IP is something they step into. Here is what it means, why it matters for brands and web3 communities, and how to make your IP playable without building a game.